THE PAYOFF OF PROBLEMS

QUICK NOTE: I’m currently writing a book that explores life lessons from the Epistle of James, loosely weaving in what we know about his life and journey of faith. This week’s blog is a condensed version of Chapter Two. As I continue writing, I'll be sharing more chapters here along the way. Stay tuned!

THE PAYOFF OF PROBLEMS
James doesn’t deal in abstract belief. He writes with urgency about a dirty-handed faith that shows up in real life and refuses to remain theoretical. He writes to people who know hardship and have endured trials. Somewhere along the way, his own foundation shifted. How does a person go from believing Jesus is just a crazy man to declaring, “I’m James, a bondservant of God and of the Lord Jesus Christ”? The straight lines of his rigid logic were broken, leaving his mind forever changed.

At the heart of his message is a new reality: faith without works is dead. Or perhaps a better translation might be that faith that never expresses itself isn’t really alive. For James, following Jesus as his brother wouldn’t work. Following Jesus as his servant, though, carried greater weight. That’s because a true life not only moves and acts, but it also breathes.
James rhetorically asks us, “Don’t you see, faith without actions is useless?” A lifeless body without breath is just that: lifeless. But if we want to understand what an alive-faith actually looks like, we need to begin where James does—with the mysterious need for trials and hardships.

WHY TRIALS MATTER
James tells us, “Count it pure joy when you fall into various trials” (James 1:2). In other words, challenges are a great opportunity for great joy!
But this is a terrible idea. And I’m sure I’m not alone when I say that this is one of the worst ideas James has possibly had.

You can ask 100 people what the secret of success is, and you’ll probably get 1,000 different ideas. We have many personal measurements, from financial independence and mastering a new skill to good health and personal fulfillment. If we were to interview James, though, he’d probably give us just one. If you want to triumph in life, the secret isn’t getting out of the trials; it’s having the determination to get through them.

James explains that the testing of our faith produces endurance, and endurance completes its work so that we may be mature and whole, lacking in nothing (James 1:2-4, NRSV). To truly understand success, then, we must also understand defeat. Problems produce perseverance, and perseverance produces maturity. So perhaps problems are the secret of many triumphs.
Is James really saying to pray for more problems? Probably not. But an alive-faith is formed through the perseverance these problems require. As a friend once said to me, “You have to know what you can get through, to know what you can do.”

Of course, not all our problems come from the same place. I’m not an expert in studying the many reasons problems arise, but I’m a masterclass in creating them. Some of my problems are born from my own decisions. Others are formed by circumstances beyond my control.

TWO KINDS OF PROBLEMS:
I. BORN FROM MY OWN DECISIONS

I’ve had someone try to explain the results of my decisions by saying something to the effect of: Either you have little shame and believe you’re not at fault for any of your problems, or you’re a martyr and believe the fault is entirely yours. I didn’t want to agree with either option. Can’t I land somewhere in the middle?

The truth is, we create difficulties through our decisions in all kinds of ways. We overcommit, avoid drafting financial budgets, make assumptions instead of listening carefully, and choose convenience over spiritual disciplines. We live reactively instead of intentionally. Poor communication can deepen wrong decisions, and shifting the blame from ourselves onto others only escalates our problems.

What about the solutions that create even more problems? Have you ever told a lie to get out of the last lie? I once read about the Chinese government’s 1958 campaign against four pests: rats, flies, mosquitoes, and sparrows. By eliminating much of the sparrow population, the government inadvertently disrupted the local ecosystem, contributing to a surge in crop-destroying pests. Their cure was worse than the disease.

We do much the same thing. We create problems over problems, then come up with our own solutions that solve nothing.

Yet even in the problems we create, God can still bring a payoff through our failures. James uses Abraham as an example of faith working together with action. Abraham believed God, and his faith was expressed through what he did (James 2:21-24). Sometimes it’s the very problem we’ve created that forces our faith to work together with our actions.

II. FORMED BY CIRCUMSTANCES
But we can’t be entirely responsible for all the trials and difficulties in our lives. Some problems are things that happen to us rather than by us.

I like the title of Kate Bowler’s book: Everything Happens for a Reason, and Other Lies I Love. I agree with her when she says, “The only thing worse than saying everything happens for a reason is pretending you know the reason.” Finding a reason for everything can prove more dismissive than helpful. We cannot be held responsible for all the difficult circumstances in our lives. You can exercise daily, stick to a healthy diet, and be in the best shape of your life, and then suddenly suffer from a debilitating disease.

One of the best biblical examples of circumstances beyond our control is Jesus and the storm. Jesus told his disciples to cross the Sea of Galilee, known for its fierce, sudden windstorms. While Jesus slept in the stern of the boat, one of those storms suddenly overtook them. Even the fishermen among them were terrified. They finally woke Jesus, asking if he cared that they were about to die. Jesus rebuked the wind and said to the sea, “Peace, be still!” (Mark 4:39, NKJV).

The wind died, and the waves ceased. Then Jesus turned to his disciples and asked, “Where is your faith?”

Sometimes life feels much like that storm. One minute we’re enjoying a calm day, and the next, the clouds gather and toss our lives back and forth. Sometimes it even feels like Jesus is sleeping away on a cushion somewhere.

When those moments come, James has something to say. If we lack wisdom, we should ask God in faith, believing that he desires to help us. We don’t have to understand every reason for our circumstances before we seek God’s wisdom. Sometimes, instead of asking for the reason, we need to ask for the way through.

WHAT TRIALS REVEAL
James moves from describing trials and testing into the subject of temptation. There are some important distinctions here. God does not tempt us. As James explains, God cannot be tempted by evil, and he himself tempts no one (James 1:13). God is your deliverer, not your deceiver.

Temptation comes from our own desires, which entice us and drag us away. Those desires give birth to sinful actions, and when sin is allowed to grow, it gives birth to death (James 1:14-15, NLT).

But temptation itself is not a sin. Jesus was tempted in every way, according to the author of Hebrews (4:15). Being tempted doesn’t mean you’re failing; it just means you’re human. You can be tempted, like Christ, and not sin—just like Christ.

Our response matters. Whether our problems come from our own decisions or circumstances beyond our control, they reveal something about the condition of our inner lives. They expose our competing loyalties, our fears, and the things we trust.
And that’s where the real work of faith begins.

THE PAYOFF
The short answer to the payoff of problems is the “crown of life that the Lord has promised to those who love him” (James 1:12, NRSV). But the longer answer is that problems can become a means of spiritual growth, helping us become more like Christ.

Our Savior and founder experienced difficulties throughout his life. If he faced rejection, betrayal, and suffering, how can we possibly think that following him means we won’t also face them?

Spiritual growth is becoming more like Christ. James and Paul seem to sing from the same hymnal, even if they use different notes. Paul writes that affliction produces endurance, endurance produces character, and character produces hope (Romans 5:3-5). Problems can produce perseverance, which in turn produces a stronger faith.

And sometimes we ask God to take us out of these difficulties before we see the fruit they might produce. Too often, we’re more interested in the gifts of the Spirit than the fruit of the Spirit. We want the gifts God provides but not always the road it takes to get there.
So how do we live through these problems with an alive faith?

James is never content to leave faith as an idea. Since problems reveal what is alive inside us, our response to those problems matters. How we listen or speak. How we carry anger or respond to difficult circumstances. James reminds us to be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to anger, because human anger does not produce God’s righteousness.

Wisdom is not only what we learn in hardship, but how we behave and respond within it. The ultimate payoff isn’t simply surviving the storm. It’s coming out the other side formed more like Christ. Trials don’t just teach us endurance. They teach us transformation.

Perhaps that’s the real payoff of problems. It’s not that we eventually get everything we wanted, that every question gets answered, or that every difficult circumstance makes sense. Sometimes the circumstances change, and sometimes they don’t. But when we allow God to work in us through them, something else begins to change. Our faith becomes more than something we believe; it becomes something we live. We learn to trust when we cannot see, to persevere when we’d rather quit, and to respond with the character of Christ when everything around us seems to pull us in another direction. That’s what James wants us to understand. The goal isn’t simply to get through our problems. It’s to become the kind of people whose faith is still alive on the other side of them.